Painful Quandary

The Brothers' War • #331 • rare

Enchantment |

🛒 Marketplace Links

Live Value $4.48

Foil Multiplier: 1.5x

Reprint Profile:

Printed 8 times HIGH RISK

Reprinted 3x in the last 2 years.

See other high reprint risk cards →

Dealer Buylist:

$1.50 ↓ 25% / 7d

Buy/Sell Spread:

vs $4.99 retail 70% WIDE

Dealers are paying well below retail. Expect to take a hit selling this one quickly.

Buylist data via MTGJSON (Card Kingdom), October 13, 2026.

Clicking links to purchase cards directly supports ManaBleed via affiliate commissions at no extra cost to your order pool.

🗂️ Alternative Printings

Compare all 8 printings & prices →

Painful Quandary

The Brothers' War • #331 • rare

Current Valuation

$4.48

30-Day Market Trend

Rarity

rare

Set Origin

BRO

Daily Shift

0.00%

EDHREC Rank

#1,193

Mana Cost

Oracle Data

Card Type Enchantment

Color Identity Black

🖋️ Curator's Notes

Whenever an opponent casts a spell, that player loses 5 life unless they discard a card.

⚖️

Official Judge Precedents

2 Precedents

2011-01-01

Whenever an opponent casts a spell, Painful Quandary's ability triggers and goes on the stack on top of it. It will resolve before the spell does.

2022-10-14

Whenever an opponent casts a spell, Painful Quandary's ability triggers and goes on the stack on top of it. It will resolve before the spell does.

📜 Technical Attributes

Release Date: 2022-11-18

Set Name: The Brothers' War

Artist Reference: David Palumbo

Border Profile: black

✨ Variants & Finishes

Available Finishes Standard • Traditional Foil

Promo Status boosterfun

Edition Status Reprint

Sanctioned Formats

standard legal

modern legal

legacy legal

commander legal

pioneer legal

pauper not_legal

vintage legal

brawl legal

explorer not_legal

penny legal

predh legal

🔍 Related Entries

Meticulous Excavation

BRO

Visions of Phyrexia

BRO