Magic Cards Illustrated by Melissa A. Benson
Displaying 231 validated market records
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$1399.99
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$879.99
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$400.0
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$250.0
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$115.0
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$88.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$80.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$79.89
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$74.99
Planar Gate
Artifact
$74.92
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$66.27
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$54.5
Norwood Priestess
Creature — Elf Druid
$43.72
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$40.47
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$38.6
Halfdane
Legendary Creature — Shapeshifter
$35.97
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$35.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$34.99
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$33.72
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$29.33
Ring of Immortals
Artifact
$28.06
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$27.24
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$26.61
Ragnar
Legendary Creature — Human Cleric
$24.7
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$22.77
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$22.56
Didgeridoo
Artifact
$21.0
Forethought Amulet
Artifact
$20.45
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$20.0
Xira Arien
Legendary Creature — Insect Wizard
$19.62
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$17.75
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$16.99
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$15.16
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$14.99
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$12.99
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$12.9
Altar of Bone
Sorcery
$11.84
Elven Riders
Creature — Elf
$10.4
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$9.9
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$9.64
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$9.52
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$7.71
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$7.58
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$6.19
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$6.05
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$5.97
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$5.97
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$5.76
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$5.59
Hand of Justice
Creature — Avatar
$5.55
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$5.49
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$5.39
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$5.12
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$4.67
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$4.43
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$4.16
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$4.15
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$3.89
Alluring Scent
Sorcery
$3.84
Alluring Scent
Sorcery
$3.58
Ichneumon Druid
Creature — Human Druid
$3.47
Rain of Daggers
Sorcery
$3.37
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$3.08
Aerathi Berserker
Creature — Human Berserker
$2.79
Segovian Leviathan
Creature — Leviathan
$2.51
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$2.37
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$2.32
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$2.06
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$2.0
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$1.88
Marble Priest
Artifact Creature — Cleric
$1.83
Syphon Soul
Sorcery
$1.79
Order of the Ebon Hand
Creature — Cleric Knight
$1.75
Truce
Instant
$1.73
Ivory Guardians
Creature — Giant Cleric
$1.66
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$1.48
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$1.47
Norwood Priestess
Creature — Elf Druid
$1.45
Sewers of Estark
Instant
$1.41
Order of the Ebon Hand
Creature — Cleric Knight
$1.34
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$1.3
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$1.28
Balduvian Hydra
Creature — Hydra
$1.19
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$1.14
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$1.11
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$1.0
Truce
Instant
$0.99
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.98
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$0.91
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.9
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.79
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$0.77
Cloud of Faeries
Creature — Faerie
$0.75
The Ultimate Nightmare of Wizards of the Coast® Customer Service
Sorcery
$0.73
Kiss of Death
Sorcery
$0.65
Yavimaya Wurm
Creature — Wurm
$0.64
Mountain Titan
Creature — Giant
$0.57
Mammoth Harness
Enchantment — Aura
$0.56
Segovian Leviathan
Creature — Leviathan
$0.55
Xira Arien
Legendary Creature — Insect Wizard
$0.54
Wiitigo
Creature — Yeti
$0.53
Syphon Soul
Sorcery
$0.53
Fiery Justice
Sorcery
$0.52
Cat Warriors
Creature — Cat Warrior
$0.47
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$0.46
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.45
Fiery Justice
Sorcery
$0.39
Sabretooth Tiger
Creature — Cat
$0.39
Rain of Daggers
Sorcery
$0.38
Get a Life
Instant
$0.38
Bronze Calendar
Artifact
$0.34
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.34
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.33
Spatula of the Ages
Artifact
$0.32
Icatian Moneychanger
Creature — Human
$0.32
Segovian Leviathan
Creature — Leviathan
$0.31
Bronze Calendar
Artifact
$0.3
Segovian Leviathan
Creature — Leviathan
$0.3
Phantasmal Mount
Creature — Illusion Horse
$0.29
Kjeldoran Dead
Creature — Skeleton
$0.28
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.27
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.26
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.26
Cloud of Faeries
Creature — Faerie
$0.26
Silver Erne
Creature — Bird
$0.25
Alluring Scent
Sorcery
$0.25
Segovian Leviathan
Creature — Leviathan
$0.24
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.22
Icatian Javelineers
Creature — Human Soldier
$0.22
Kjeldoran Elite Guard
Creature — Human Soldier
$0.21
Rain of Daggers
Sorcery
$0.21
Touch of Death
Sorcery
$0.21
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.21
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$0.2
Vodalian Soldiers
Creature — Merfolk Soldier
$0.2
Elven Riders
Creature — Elf
$0.2
Order of the Ebon Hand
Creature — Cleric Knight
$0.2
Cat Warriors
Creature — Cat Warrior
$0.2
Kjeldoran Dead
Creature — Skeleton
$0.2
Adarkar Sentinel
Artifact Creature — Soldier
$0.2
Cemetery Gate
Creature — Wall
$0.19
Ghitu Slinger
Creature — Human Nomad
$0.19
Ivory Guardians
Creature — Giant Cleric
$0.19
Farrel's Zealot
Creature — Human
$0.18
Cemetery Gate
Creature — Wall
$0.18
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.18
Orcish Veteran
Creature — Orc
$0.17
Thelon's Chant
Enchantment
$0.17
Kjeldoran Elite Guard
Creature — Human Soldier
$0.17
Ghitu Fire-Eater
Creature — Human Nomad
$0.15
About Face
Instant
$0.15
Cat Warriors
Creature — Cat Warrior
$0.15
Centaur Archer
Creature — Centaur Archer
$0.15
Funeral March
Enchantment — Aura
$0.14
Kjeldoran Dead
Creature — Skeleton
$0.14
Cat Warriors
Creature — Cat Warrior
$0.14
About Face
Instant
$0.14
Vodalian Soldiers
Creature — Merfolk Soldier
$0.14
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$0.14
Ghitu Slinger
Creature — Human Nomad
$0.13
Kjeldoran Dead
Creature — Skeleton
$0.13
Sabretooth Tiger
Creature — Cat
$0.12
Touch of Death
Sorcery
$0.11
Yavimaya Wurm
Creature — Wurm
$0.11
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.1
Syphon Soul
Sorcery
$0.09
Sabretooth Tiger
Creature — Cat
$0.08
Vodalian Soldiers
Creature — Merfolk Soldier
$0.07
Sewers of Estark
Instant
$0.0
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.0
Kjeldoran Elite Guard
Creature — Human Soldier
$0.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$0.0
Ragnar
Legendary Creature — Human Cleric
$0.0
Hand of Justice
Creature — Avatar
$0.0
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.0
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$0.0
Elven Riders
Creature — Elf
$0.0
Orcish Catapult
Instant
$0.0
Elven Riders
Creature — Elf
$0.0
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.0
Cat Warriors
Creature — Cat Warrior
$0.0
Adarkar Sentinel
Artifact Creature — Soldier
$0.0
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$0.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$0.0
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.0
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$0.0
Alluring Scent
Sorcery
$0.0
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$0.0
Kjeldoran Dead
Creature — Skeleton
$0.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$0.0
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$0.0
Balduvian Hydra
Creature — Hydra
$0.0
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.0
Hand of Justice
Creature — Avatar
$0.0
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.0
Centaur Archer
Creature — Centaur Archer
$0.0
Xira Arien
Legendary Creature — Insect Wizard
$0.0
Didgeridoo
Artifact
$0.0
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$0.0
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$0.0
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$0.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$0.0
Elven Riders
Creature — Elf
$0.0
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$0.0
Fire Elemental
Creature — Elemental
$0.0
Holy Armor
Enchantment — Aura
$0.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$0.0
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$0.0
Icatian Javelineers
Creature — Human Soldier
$0.0
Planar Gate
Artifact
$0.0
Halfdane
Legendary Creature — Shapeshifter
$0.0
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.0
Norwood Priestess
Creature — Elf Druid
$0.0
Lord of Atlantis
Creature — Merfolk
$0.0
Timber Wolves
Creature — Wolf
$0.0
Elven Riders
Creature — Elf
$0.0
Ivory Guardians
Creature — Giant Cleric
$0.0
Ivory Guardians
Creature — Giant Cleric
$0.0
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$0.0
Cloud of Faeries
Creature — Faerie
$0.0
Wiitigo
Creature — Yeti
$0.0
Xira Arien
Legendary Creature — Insect Wizard
$0.0
Angel of Mercy
Creature — Angel
$0.0
Mesa Pegasus
Creature — Pegasus
$0.0
Rain of Daggers
Sorcery
$0.0
Phantasmal Mount
Creature — Illusion Horse
$0.0
Xira Arien
Legendary Creature — Insect Wizard
$0.0
Segovian Leviathan
Creature — Leviathan
$0.0
Nightmare
Creature — Nightmare Horse
$0.0
Shivan Dragon
Creature — Dragon
$0.0